France's Le Pen accused of plagiarising Fillon speech

The similarities between the speeches drew online accusations of plagiarism, but aides of French far-right presidential candidate Marine Le Pen brushed off the criticism.

Photo by: Reuters
Photo by: Reuters

French National Front (FN) presidential candidate Marine Le Pen during a campaign rally in Villepinte, near Paris, France, May 1, 2017.

French far-right presidential candidate MarineĀ LeĀ PenĀ came under fire on social media on Tuesday for lifting sections of a speech from her conservative rival FrancoisĀ Fillon.

Although the speech caused an online sensation over plagiarism, it appeared to be an attempt by LeĀ PenĀ to reach out to supporters of Francois Fillon. FillonĀ was knocked out in the April 23 first round of voting after coming in third with 20 percent of the vote.

Polls showĀ LeĀ PenĀ lagging behind centrist front runner Emmanuel Macron by aboutĀ 20 points before next Sunday's runoff, and she needs to broaden her base to stand a chance of winning. Fillon has urged voters to back Macron.

TRT World's Sarah MoriceĀ brings more from Paris

In one part of her May 1 speech, lasting about 50 seconds,Ā LeĀ PenĀ talked about peopleĀ learning French in Argentina and Poland, and on waiting lists to study at the Alliance Francaise official French schools abroad, in a word-per-word lifting of a mid-April speech by Fillon.

LeĀ PenĀ added to Fillon's comment, sayingĀ this showed France is more than a military and industrial power, that France "must and can" become a big power again.

It was the second most trending topic on Twitter in France, with the hashtag #plagiat, plagiarism in French.

One Twitter user, @RidiculeTV, posted a video of both speeches.

The incident had echoes of an incident during last year's US presidential election when a writer for then-candidate Donald Trump's campaign apologised for a speech by Trump's wife Melania that drew accusations of plagiarism from a speech earlier given by former First Lady Michelle Obama.


The National Front (FN) candidate's team was unrepentant, however. Florian Philippot, an FN deputyĀ leader, said the party "completely owned up" to the fact that the speech resembled one by Fillon.

LeĀ PenĀ also described France's borders and ties with "Italy, our sister" ā€“Ā again a phrase used in Fillon's April 15 speech, and used the same quote from early 20th century French Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau.

In another excerpt about prospects of cooperation with France's neighbours, where the words were again the same as in Fillon's speech,Ā LeĀ PenĀ added that this would require France not being "a vassal" of Germany.

French newspapers and social media highlighted the similarities, butĀ LeĀ PenĀ aides brushed off the criticism.

Philippot told Radio Classique thatĀ LeĀ Pen's speech was a "nod-and-a-wink" to Fillon's speech in order to "launch a real debate" about French identity.

LeĀ Pen's campaign manager David Rachline also played down plagiarism accusations, painting her speech as a form of tribute to Fillon. The reference "was appreciated, including by all of MrĀ Fillon's supporters," Rachline told France 2 television.

There was no immediate comment from Fillon.

TRTWorld and agencies