Centre-right mayor beats socialist as Brazil voters elect mayors

The mayor of the largest city in the Americas has easily fended off a reelection challenge from the socialist leader of a squatters movement as 57 Brazilian cities held runoff elections.

Mayor Bruno Covas had just under 60 percent of the votes to 40 percent for Guilherme Boulos, who had been backed by former President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.

Covas, the grandson of a former state governor and presidential candidate, is a close ally of current Sao Paulo state Governor Joao Doria, his predecessor as mayor, and the strong showing boosts Doria's presidential aspirations for the centre-right Brazilian Social Democracy Party.

Covas, 40, celebrated his victory at his party's headquarters hand in hand with Doria.

'Common sense'

“Sao Paulo said yes to moderation, to balance,” the mayor said. Covas added that “there are a few days left for denialists,” a message his allies interpreted as a swipe at President Jair Bolsonaro, who downplays the risks of the coronavirus and challenges health protocols aimed at limiting the impact of the pandemic.

Doria, who Bolsonaro considers one of his biggest adversaries, said Covas' victory came from “moderation, common sense and management skills.”

Covas, who inherited the job two years ago after Doria resigned to run for governor, campaigned on his performance leading the city of 12 million people through the coronavirus crisis, helping set up field hospitals and pushing for restrictions on activity while challenging Bolsonaro's dismissal of the pandemic's seriousness. A cancer survivor, Covas also recovered from a bout with the virus in June.

Boulos, the 38-year-old son of university professors, decided at age 16 to become a community organiser in poor areas of the city and hasn't left since, still living in a poor neighbourhood with his wife and two daughters. Even with a defeat, he is expected to become one of the most important leftist leaders in Brazil after propelling himself into the mayoral runoff.

Boulos conceded from the balcony of his house, where he is isolating due to testing positive for the coronavirus.

“We will win. It wasn't in this election, but we will win,” he told a small crowd in front of his house. “A lot of people have hope again. That was the biggest victory of our campaign. Today was not the end of a campaign. It was the beginning.”

READ MORE: Covid-19 has created a global infodemic, but Brazil and India are unique 

Hopes for Brazil’s battered left

One of the leaders of the Homeless Workers Movement, Boulos became known for organising invasions of empty buildings in downtown Sao Paulo, arguing they should be shared by homeless families.

The emergence of Boulos, of the Socialism and Liberty Party, has raised hopes in Brazil’s battered left, long led by da Silva, with his success in drawing crowds to his campaign rallies.

Da Silva's Workers' Party lost its two runoffs in state capitals, in the cities of Recife and Vitoria, and only scored some wins in mid-size cities. It had 254 mayors in 2016, in an election that was considered disastrous for the party, and it shrank further this year to 183.

Doria's party also shrank nationally despite the major win in Sao Paulo. It had 785 mayors and will start next year with 520.

Boulos's party elected Edmilson Rodrigues as the mayor of Belem, the Amazon metropolis.

Both mayoral candidates in Sao Paulo oppose Bolsonaro, whose favoured candidate in the mayoral race finished fourth in first-round voting two weeks ago, with half as many votes as Boulos.

READ MORE: Facebook globally blocks 12 of Brazil's Bolsonaro allies

Important candidate

Alberto Bueno, a partner at the consulting firm Concordia, said the socialist candidate might become an important leader even in defeat.

“Boulos managed to win over a young audience and energised leftist anti-Bolsonaro voters," Bueno said, adding, "It will depend on his political skill to project his leadership beyond Sao Paulo.”

The conservative Bolsonaro campaigned for some candidates during his live broadcasts on social media in recent weeks, but few of them won.

The president’s biggest setback, other than Sao Paulo, came in his hometown of Rio de Janeiro. Former Mayor Eduardo Paes won his job back in a 64 percent-36 percent victory over incumbent Marcelo Crivella, who tried to compensate his unpopularity with a close relationship to the president.

In his first speech after being elected, Paes was accompanied by lower house speaker Rodrigo Maia, who has a tense relationship with the president.

“There has been too much hate, too much division. That is not good to Rio citizens, to Brazilian citizens," said Paes.

Carlos Melo, a political science professor at Insper University in Sao Paulo, said there were no big surprises in the most important runoffs.

“Bolsonaro lost, the Workers' Party lost, and some centrist and centre-right parties won a lot. It was not too different from the first round,” Melo said. “Some of those parties that elected many mayors are still in Bolsonaro's base, but they can slip away from him.”

READ MORE: Video of Cabinet meeting puts Brazil's Bolsonaro under fire