Argentina bears 'responsibility' for 1924 Indigenous massacre

The "responsibility of the state" had been proven in "crimes against humanity" that had taken place in the context of an "Indigenous genocide," says Argentinian court.

Only about a million of Argentina's 45 million inhabitants today are members or descendants of the original 39 Indigenous groups, according to census data.
AFP

Only about a million of Argentina's 45 million inhabitants today are members or descendants of the original 39 Indigenous groups, according to census data.

An Argentinian court has found the state responsible for the massacre of more than 400 Indigenous people almost a century ago and ordered remedial measures.

After a month of hearings in a so-called "truth trial," a verdict was delivered on Thursday by a court in Resistencia in Spanish as well as the languages of the Qom and Moqoit.

It said that the "responsibility of the state" had been proven in "crimes against humanity" that had taken place in the context of an "Indigenous genocide."

Judge Zunilda Niremperger ordered "historic reparations," which did not include financial compensation.

Among the measures are to include the massacre in the school syllabus and continuing forensic efforts to find the remains of victims.

Indigenous people mowed down in 1924

In July 1924, Argentinian police and settlers mowed down hundreds of Indigenous people protesting inhumane living and working conditions on cotton plantations in the northern region of Chaco.

As many as 500 members of the Qom and Moqoit communities were killed. They lived in conditions of "semi-slavery" on the so-called Napapli reservation on land settled by immigrant farmers from Europe.

A federal judge has previously ruled the mass killing a crime against humanity, but no classic criminal trial has been held given the lack of defendants – who are long dead.

Until Thursday, no guilt has ever been officially assigned.

A memorial was erected in 2020.

The plaintiffs had not sought economic redress, but the judgment could in theory pave the way for civil action.

Raquel Esquivel, a Qom descendent, told the AFP news agency it was high time that "Indigenous voices are heard."

"It’s important that the truth be told," she told AFP by telephone from Machagai, a small town near the Napalpi reserve some 1,000 kilometres north of Buenos Aires.

This was the first court case to delve into the persecution of Indigenous peoples in Argentina.

On verge of extermination

According to the accounts of survivors of the 1924 massacre, the dead included many children and the elderly.

"The wounded who could not escape were killed in the cruelest way possible," the court found – many were mutilated and buried in mass graves.

Only about a million of Argentina's 45 million inhabitants today are members or descendants of the original 39 Indigenous groups, according to census data.

Historians say the settlement of Argentina by immigrants left its Indigenous peoples on the verge of extermination.

One of the most brutal episodes, known as The Desert Campaign, saw at least 14,000 Indigenous people killed between 1878 and 1885 in the effort to incorporate Patagonia into the rest of Argentina.

READ MORE: Argentinian police suspected of 'disappearing' indigenous rights protester

Route 6