EUROPE
5 MIN READ
Why are vaccine passports so controversial in the UK?
Critics have questioned the UK government's approach towards vaccine passports as lacking scientific backing, while supporters claim it could save lives.
Why are vaccine passports so controversial in the UK?
Proof of vaccine status can be given using a smartphone app. / AP

British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has faced his worst rebellion with more than 100 members of his party rejecting the introduction of Covid-19 passports. The measures only passed after the opposition parties banded together and approved the government's measures.

One right-wing magazine made a list of all the members of parliament who voted for the vaccine's passport, calling it a "roll of shame."

Only in September, the government denied that it would be introducing vaccine passports amidst widespread opposition from within the party and voters.

An official petition of those against a vaccine passport on the parliamentary website gathered almost 400,000 signatures and even demonstrations.

The government's response to the petition earlier this year said, "we can't discriminate against people who, for whatever reason, haven't had a vaccine."

That u-turn has been decried as a betrayal by some on the right who argue that the state has no business in controlling what people can and can't do.

So what do the measures mean?

Following the measures being passed in the UK parliament, people in England will now need to show their Covid status to get into nightclubs, music venues, shopping centres and many other venues that are open to large numbers of people.

Controversial for some is that the government has changed the definition of what it means to be fully vaccinated. As a result, people that have received the two vaccine shots will no longer be considered "fully vaccinated" unless they have the third booster shot.

Scientists have said that over time, immunity to Covid-19 decreases, and with the emergence of the new Omicron variant - it's important to get an additional shot.

Some critics, including anti-vaxxers, feel that the constant shifting of goalposts means that the government can't be trusted and that vaccine passports are a means for the state to extend its reach into people's lives.

When members of parliament earlier this year asked the government to provide scientific evidence on whether covid passports work, it received no response leading to a scathing report.

"With recent analysis suggesting that vaccinated people carry as much of the virus as the unvaccinated into any setting, the disappointing lack of any scientific basis for the Government's decision to go ahead could reasonably lead people to conclude that there is, in fact, no such basis," concluded one member of parliament in a report on the government's plans on covid passports.

It then added that "If the real goal is to drive vaccine uptake, then it is a deeply cynical approach that will be counterproductive."

It added that any policy on vaccines passports that was not based on science would be "discriminatory and, potentially, ineffective policy will have consequences for trust in and acceptance of the Government's measures to tackle the pandemic."

The UK government is also extending its vaccine passport coverage to 12 and 15-year-olds which has also met resistance amongst skeptics.

One British politician voting against the current restrictions called predictions on mass deaths "pessimistic and wrong."

As part of the measures, it will now become compulsory for medical staff in hospitals to be vaccinated.

One of the largest health unions in England opposed the decision calling it a "strong-arm tactic," adding that it was "opposed to legally enforced medical procedures as a condition of employment – it's heavy-handed."

An opposition member of parliament who also voted against the decision remarked that legally forcing workers to get vaccinated or face being fired was an unprecedented move in the country.

"For the first time ever, we have seen the profession of care workers singled out and have conditions attached to their employment status which was never there to begin with," said the politician urging the government to persuade workers rather than using such measures.

SOURCE:TRT World
Explore
Belgian police face complaints over alleged violence against young protesters
UN warns of rising tensions in Kosovo despite signs of political progress
Ukraine's Zelenskyy confirms US intelligence sharing resumes as Oslo talks begin
Russia expands strikes on Ukraine's energy grid, leaving thousands without power
Albania protests continue as fresh clashes erupt in Tirana
Macron begins Gulf tour to secure fuel supplies as cost-of-living protests rock France
Flight from Israel makes emergency landing in Bulgaria amid bomb threat
Paris erupts again as police clash with protesters and new looting hits France
Nearly 200 arrested as education and budget protests turn violent in Belgium
Albania protests enter sixth day as Rama rejects calls to resign
Zelenskyy warns US’ Russia sanctions relief could reward Putin and fuel more attacks
Marseille town hall breached as France braces for nationwide cost-of-living protests
UK and France express support for Ukraine amid growing Trump-Zelenskyy row
Barcelona grinds to a halt as farmers rally with 200 tractors over agricultural crisis
Bulgaria moves to join NATO anti-drone initiative after Black Sea ship sinks
Fire engulfs Albania's education ministry as student protests escalate
Europe’s weak link: The scandals eroding trust in Germany’s BND
French students continue school blockades ahead of talks with officials
Russian missile hits Kiev power plant as Zelenskyy flags lack of Western warning
UN condemns Black Sea drone attacks, warns of risks to global food supplies